ADVENTURELAND isn't as funny as I thought it would be. That's because it's not really a comedy — a dramedy at best. Ads have played up the humor and that it's written and directed by SUPERBAD's Greg Mottola, who used what power he earned on the Judd Apatow-produced comedy to revisit this story, which he had written years before. It's a personal '80s coming-of-age story that feels authentic due to its keen feel for setting and tone. While many of the characters could be described in a few words, it wouldn't tell you all there is to tell about them. Just like life.
James Brennan (Jesse Eisenberg, THE SQUID AND THE WHALE) has just graduated college and is looking forward to a summer trip cavorting around Europe with his friends before starting grad school at Columbia. However, his parents give him surprise news on his graduation day — his father has been demoted and they don't have the money to send him to Europe or pay for his apartment in NYC. So he has to go back home to Pittsburgh and find a job. The only work he can get is at the old school amusement park Adventureland.
There he meets a collection of oddball characters. Bobby (Bill Hader, SNL) and Paulette (Kristen Wiig, GHOST TOWN) are the unflappable couple who run the amusement park. Well, Bobby does get a little heated around litterbugs. James' old friend Frigo (Matt Bush, ONE LAST THING) has an obsession with punching guys in the balls when they least expect it. Joel (Martin Starr, KNOCKED UP), who shows James the con of the amusement park games, is one of those eccentric looking guys who only extenuates his eccentricities by smoking a pipe. Mike Connell (Ryan Reynolds, DEFINITELY, MAYBE) is the cool older guy who only works maintenance at the park so he can play in a band at night. You know the kind of guy who comes to the park with his guitar for no other reason than it makes him look cool, and helps sell his story about jamming with Lou Reed. Lisa P (Margarita Levieva, THE INVISIBLE) is the town tease, a good Catholic girl who dresses like she should be saying Hail Marys all day long. But James can't resist Em (Kristen Stewart, TWILIGHT). She's the cool rocker girl who seems to have it all together. That's until you see what her life is really like.
What struck me most is that the film doesn't judge its characters. It presents them as they are. It doesn't apologize for the characters it wants us to like when they do wrong and it doesn't demonize the characters it wants us not to like. A perfect example of this is with Connell and Lisa P. Connell puts on a good front, but it's easy to see he's a fraud. But the film doesn't need to force some comeuppance upon him. Lisa P is shallow and not too bright, but even she gets to have a deep moment or two where Mottola doesn't pull the rug out from under her to make her depth just the butt of a joke.
This non-judgmental tone also stretches to its main characters. James is a 21-year-old virgin, but the film doesn't make it out like he has to fix that problem to be normal. And yet, the film is honest about James being a 21-year-old virgin. Moral stances he took when he was younger aren't as firm anymore. Kristen's budding relationship with James has more behind it then girl meets cute nice guy. Her rocky home life has led to rocky relationships, none of which could be called commitments. And just because these two have seen each other doesn't mean the rest of the world around them has stopped looking.
While the film is set in the 1980s, the film isn't a '80s spoof. It has the bright flashy clothing and the asymmetrical hairstyles, but Mottola resists the urge to make those questionable fashion choices the main punchline to every joke. For those raised in the Reagan era, you just have to think, "what were we thinking?" More importantly what ADVENTURELAND gets right is the feel of a summer job and a summer romance. Working at the amusement park with its repetitive soundtrack playing over crappy speakers and puking children is not too much fun, but the people you work with make it the best time of your life. The guy who threatens to stab you over a stuffed animal is crazy, but it makes for a great story to tell. Each day is a new adventure and that's how being young feels sometimes. That's why the film's title is so perfect, because the adventure this film is about is the adventure of being young.